Army Tribunal Confirms Censure for Brigadier in Poonch Civilian Deaths Case

The Armed Forces Tribunal has upheld an administrative censure against a brigadier who was in command of a sector of the Rashtriya Rifles in Jammu and Kashmir’s Poonch district during a tragic incident in December 2023 that resulted in the deaths of three civilians. This decision comes after retired Brigadier P Acharya challenged the Army’s severe reprimand directed towards him.

The incident dates back to December 22, 2023, when military personnel detained nine villagers from Topa Peer following a militant attack that had claimed the lives of four soldiers just a day earlier. Among those detained were Safeer Ahmad (45), Mohammad Showkat (26), and Shabir Ahmad (30), all of whom reportedly died due to alleged torture while in military custody. The fatalities raised serious concerns regarding the treatment of civilians during military operations in conflict zones.

The tribunal, sitting in Chandigarh, examined the circumstances surrounding the incident, noting that the commanding officer of the 48 Rashtriya Rifles battalion involved had ordered company commanders to employ “slightly harsh” interrogation techniques. Such directives, the tribunal pointed out, were a clear indication of a failure in leadership and oversight. Furthermore, it was highlighted that Brigadier Acharya himself had exhibited aggression, having physically assaulted a suspect, which contributed to the environment of brutality during interrogations.

In its ruling, the tribunal emphasized the need for accountability, especially in military operations that directly affect civilian lives. The panel stated, “In the context of the ongoing conflict, it is imperative that military personnel exercise utmost restraint and professionalism when interacting with civilians.” This ruling serves as a stark reminder of the consequences of failing to adhere to established protocols during sensitive operations.

As the situation continues to evolve in Jammu and Kashmir, this case underscores the urgent need for the Indian Army to address human rights concerns and the conduct of its personnel in civilian areas. The tribunal’s decision not only aims to hold individuals responsible but also to ensure that similar incidents do not occur in the future, paving the way for more respectful and lawful engagement with the civilian population.

Source: scroll.in